1. Start with what you actually need
Before you compare agencies, get clear on the job. Do you need someone to set the strategy, someone to run things day to day, or someone to make you look great? Some agencies are full service, some specialise in one channel and some are design studios that also do a bit of digital. None of those is wrong, but the best agency for a rebrand isn't always the best one for Google Ads.
Write down the two or three outcomes that matter most this year, such as more enquiries, more bookings or a stronger brand, and judge every agency against those.
2. Ask who will do the work
In a lot of agencies the person who pitches isn't the person who plans your campaigns, and the person who plans them isn't the person who builds them. Every hand off is a chance for the brief to get lost. Ask to meet the people who'll be on your account day to day.
3. Look for real island experience
Guernsey and Jersey are small markets with their own habits. Audiences are tight, people see the same ads a lot, word of mouth moves fast and a UK playbook rarely fits without changes. An agency that has run campaigns here will know how to manage frequency, which local media still matters and where the two islands behave differently. Ask for examples of island campaigns, not just UK ones.
4. Check how they measure results
Good marketing is measured properly. Your agency should set up tracking so you can see enquiries, calls, bookings or sales, not just clicks and impressions. Ask what they'll track, how often they'll report and what a report looks like. If they can show you a real example, even better.
5. Understand how you'll be charged
Agencies charge in different ways: monthly retainers, hourly rates, project fees or a percentage of ad spend. Whichever it is, you should know exactly what's included, what costs extra and how much notice you need to give. Keep ad spend separate from fees so you can see where your money goes, and make sure your ad accounts and data are set up in your business's name.
6. Look at the work and the reviews
Case studies show you what an agency is proud of. Look for ones with clear goals and results, from businesses like yours. Then check their Google reviews and, if you can, ask to speak to a current client. Ten minutes on the phone will tell you more than any pitch deck.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Who will work on my account day to day?
- What would you focus on in the first 90 days?
- How will you track results, and how often will we review them?
- Will my ad accounts, website and data be in my name?
- What's included in the fee and what costs extra?
- What's the notice period?
- Can I speak to a current client?
A few red flags
- Guaranteed rankings or guaranteed results. Nobody can promise where Google will put you.
- Long contracts before you've seen any work.
- Ad accounts set up in the agency's name, so you lose your history if you leave.
- Reports full of impressions and reach, with nothing about enquiries or sales.
Where Genie fits
We're a small marketing and creative agency in St Peter Port, working with businesses across Guernsey and Jersey. The people you meet are the people doing the work, we take tracking seriously and we report in plain English. If that sounds like what you're after, we'd love to hear from you. If not, these questions will still help you find the right fit.